Best Non-Toxic Drugstore Cosmetics

From Revlon to Physicians Formula, there are tons of non-toxic drugstore makeup products out there; you just need to do your research. To keep life simple for you, I did the dirty work and was surprised that brands I thought would be nearly entirely non-toxic were not and vice-versa. And honestly, finding cosmetics and beauty products that fit the zero to “almost” non-toxic criteria is pretty hard to find at a drugstore (or anywhere), but I did find success with a few brands I already love and respect!

non-toxic drugstore makeup products

To find which products were considered non-toxic, I used an app called Think Dirty that I highly recommend you download if you are trying to live a non-toxic lifestyle. When I looked for drugstore beauty products, I made sure they were in the 0-3 ranges for non-toxicity. Obviously, it’s better to have all of your makeup products near the 0 range, but it’s very hard to do and still get quality makeup that does something beyond tinting your lips a berry shade that comes off in 5 seconds.

And, to be authentic with you in my stance on toxic cosmetics, I don’t claim to live a non-toxic beauty lifestyle. However, if I can find a beauty product that is non-toxic and still has the quality I want for durability, coverage, etc…I would use it. I find though that a lot of eye shadow lack in pigment and staying power when they hit the 0-2 non-toxic categories, and I mine as well just not go through the effort of doing my eyes at that point. Does that make sense? I need my eyeshadow to stay…I am a mom of three; I don’t have time to a makeup touch-up, like, ever.


Anyways, here is a list of my favorite beauty products that are drugstore and (nearly) non-toxic.


  1. Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick: There are lots of lipstick colors from Revlon that are only a three on Think Dirty. I was utterly shocked actually because you can find these drugstore lipsticks virtually anywhere. If you like Revlon lipsticks and want a non-toxic color, the Revlon Super Lustrious Lipstick in Pearl, Crème and Matte has tons with a 3 rating. Here are my most favorite colors for you to choose: Revlon Matte 001 Nude Attitude Lipstick,
  2. Physicians Formula Bronze Booster Glow: Truly, Physicians Formula has way more non-toxic cosmetic options that rate a 3 than I thought possible for a drugstore brand. I already am a huge fan of their bronzers because they stay put and blend well. So, give this one a try!
  3. Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Natural Origin Mascara: Here is the good news; you can find nearly non-toxic mascara at a drugstore! All of the Physicians Formula Organic Mascara’s rate a 3 on Think Dirty and they do an awesome job of making your eyes pop.
  4. Pacifica Stellar Gaze Mascara: Another mascara option that is 100% non-toxic and found at Target in-store and on-line. Check out the Pacifica Stellar Gaze Mascara that rates zero. With that said, it’s going to essentially just tint your lashes and give a little bit of length.
  5. W3ll People Narcissist Foundation Stick: Lucky for all of us, W3LL People is now found at Target on-line and has tons of mostly non-toxic cosmetics that rate a 3. This foundation stick is ideal for low to medium coverage dependent on how much is used. I highly recommend using this product with a beauty blender for best results. Also, you just need to check out W3LL People Cosmetics, in general; your life will change forever.
  6. Pacifica Alight Multi-Mineral BB Cream: Oh hello there completely non-toxic BB Cream/ Tinted Moisturizer found at Target on-line! It’s a zero guy’s, a zero…and this BB cream get’s great ratings in general. So, give this product a go.
  7. A few others to try from Pacifica: Here are some other nearly non-toxic cosmetics that can be found at Target: Pacifica Mystical Supernatural Eye Shadow (3), Pacifica Beauty Natural Quench Lip Tint (2), Pacifica Radiant Shimmer (3).
  8. Neutrogena Naturals Lip Balm: While most everything else for Neutrogena is NOT non-toxic, there Natural Lip Balm rates at a 1! That’s pretty impressive in my opinion because I love this stuff!


What non-toxic cosmetics do you love that is drugstore?

xo, Kendra
There are affiliate links within this post. Please see affiliate page for details.
Are you on The List? Join the Citizens of Beauty newsletter for insider events, behind the scenes photos, and exclusive beauty tips and tricks to your inbox!
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.
Tags from the story
, , , ,