Guys, it’s a difficult task finding non-toxic drugstore eyeshadow brands that are actually safe. But, I have found a few that are pretty good and at a decent price point from several cosmetic companies. If you are looking to avoid parabens, phthalates and other yucky ingredients in your eyeshadow palettes, scroll down and see my top non-toxic drugstore makeup picks.
I want to clarify though when I go to the ingredient lists for each of these cosmetic companies; they spell out exactly what they don’t use in their eyeshadows. I have no idea what their testing process is to make sure everything is non-toxic and safe for you. But, if you want a safer cosmetic option that is less expensive and found at a drugstore, these brands are your best bet.
NON-TOXIC DRUGSTORE EYESHADOW BRAND #1: PACIFICA
I think Pacifica is not bad for a safer eyeshadow palette. They are committed to making sure your products are free from the yucky stuff. With that said, I have never been the hugest fan of their color quality and sometimes I feel like the eyeshadow is too powdery. Pacifica does have a good color selection with their palettes that are perfect for every day and some that are sassy and fun. I would just recommend using a non-toxic concealer before applying for better pigment.
#2 W3LL PEOPLE
W3ll People has a store here in Austin, but you can also find it at Target! I love their single eyeshadow pods for quick and easy makeup and obviously that they are a non-toxic eyeshadow option. Their price point is a little higher than what you would expect to pay at a drugstore but non-the less, still pretty good.
#3 PIXI DRUGSTORE EYESHADOW BRAND
I can’t speak for everything from PIXI, but I do know that their eyeshadows are free from gross ingredients. For the most part, I like PIXI eyeshadows but have found some to be a little too sparkly. It can be hit or miss with some of their palette colors, but they are a great price point.
#4 NON-TOXIC DRUGSTORE EYESHADOW SHEA MOISTURE
Shea Moisture brands itself as pretty safe and non-toxic, but their eyeshadows are middle of the road. They don’t have parabens and phthalates, but they also aren’t as strict with their ingredients like the others brands I am showing you. With that said, they are also the cheapest drugstore eyeshadow on the list. Their eyeshadows are ok with pigment; not my favorite.
#5 HONEYBEE SAFE DRUGSTORE EYESHADOW
Ok, HONEYBEE has some seriously cute eyeshadow palettes that claim to be free from junky ingredients. Their eyeshadows are a great price point, and the colors are gorgeous for fun eyes. If you are looking for bold colors to wear on your eyes, you will love this brand.
Hope you guys have a great day!
YOU SHOULD READ THIS NEXT
ULTIMATE GUIDE TO NON-TOXIC MAKEUP
BEAUTYCOUNTER SPRING EYESHADOW PALETTE AND TUTORIAL
5 HEALTHY BEAUTY BRANDS TO LOVE
note- there are affiliate links in this post.